Puzzle #3 · Grocery
It is November 9, 2026, and puzzle #3 has a price. Before the spoiler: Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz Jar is not as obvious as it looks, and the difficulty rating reads Easy. Play the board first, then open the answer when you are ready. The hints come before the answer, so you can peek at those first.
This puzzle is scheduled for November 9, 2026. The answer is included below for search and reference, but the daily board unlocks on its date.
It takes roughly 540 peanuts to fill one 12-ounce jar of peanut butter.
These are the same three hints the game uses, in order. They never name the price. Reveal one, think, then decide whether you need the next.
Aisle seven energy: jars, spreads and shelf-stable pantry heroes.
The classic big jar with the screw lid, the one you have to stir if it is all natural.
It's under five dollars, somewhere in the three-to-five bracket.
The board below is the real puzzle. Archive rounds do not affect your daily streak.
40 oz jar
Hints are free. Using one adds a lightbulb to your shared result.
Real price
Archived puzzle #3. Play it any time; archive rounds do not change your daily streak.
Costcodle asks you to guess one price in six tries. A guess within 5% of $4.49 would win, a guess within 25% would show yellow, and anything further away would show red. The arrows tell you whether the real price is higher or lower than the number you stamped, which is how you build a narrowing price corridor.
This puzzle appeared on November 9, 2026 in Season 1. Category: Grocery. Difficulty: Easy (1/5). Listing price: $4.49 for 40 oz jar.
Questions
The Costcodle answer for November 9, 2026 (puzzle #3) was Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz Jar, priced at $4.49. You win if your guess lands within 5% of that price.
It cost $4.49 (40 oz jar). This is the listing price used in the game, so prices shown elsewhere may differ.